Name: Rethink
Brand: Magic: The Gathering
Availability: InStock
Author: Matt Cavotta

            EN
            NM ▾
            Normal ▾
            
            + Add
          
Card

                  
                  
                  
                  Mana3
                  TypeInstant
                  
                
RethinkProphecy

                #42
                Instant
              
TCGplayer
ConditionMarketLow
Near Mint$2.55$3.00
Lightly Played$1.11$2.33
Moderately Played$0.60$2.10
Heavily Played—$1.74
Damaged—$7.43
Snapshot as of 2026-10-27. Live prices & recent sales load below.
TCGplayerRecent saleseBay
Loading…
Loading…
Card details
          
          Mana cost3
          TypeInstant
          
          
          
          
          SetProphecy
          Number42
          RarityInstant
          Released2000-06-05
        Oracle textCounter target spell unless its controller pays X, where X is its converted mana cost.
Illustrated by Matt Cavotta

        Flavor
        "Are you sure you want to do that?"
      
Protect this card
          
          
            
            
            10% off · code CARDPRICES
            Sleeves, toploaders & binders
            Everything that keeps Rethink in the grade it is in.
            Shop BCW ↗
          
          
            
            
            10% off · code card-prices
            Display & slab cases
            For the cards worth showing, not just storing.
            Shop Zion ↗
          
        
Sponsored Affiliate links: Card Prices earns a commission on qualifying purchases from BCW and Zion Cases, at no extra cost to you.

Rethink price & value

Rethink

Card details

Oracle text

Flavor

Protect this card

More by Matt Cavotta ↗

Condition	Market	Low
Near Mint	$2.55	$3.00
Lightly Played	$1.11	$2.33
Moderately Played	$0.60	$2.10
Heavily Played	—	$1.74
Damaged	—	$7.43