Magic: The Gathering/ Fifth Edition
Card
CARD PRICES

Eye for an Eye price & value

EN NM ▾ Normal ▾ + Add
Eye for an Eye — Fifth Edition
Card
Mana
2
Type
Instant

Eye for an Eye

Fifth Edition
Instant
TCGplayer
ConditionMarketLow
Near Mint$0.63$1.99
Lightly Played$0.50$1.88
Moderately Played$0.39$1.83
Heavily Played$0.47$1.87
Damaged$0.44$1.89

Snapshot as of 2026-10-27. Live prices & recent sales load below.

TCGplayerRecent saleseBay
Loading…
Loading…

Card details

Mana cost
2
Type
Instant
Set
Fifth Edition
Rarity
Instant
Released
1997-03-24

Oracle text

Play only when a creature, spell, or effect assigns damage to you. Eye for an Eye deals an equal amount of damage to that source’s controller.

Illustrated by Mark Poole

Protect this card

BCW Supplies 10% off · code CARDPRICES Sleeves, toploaders & binders Everything that keeps Eye for an Eye in the grade it is in. Shop BCW ↗ Zion Cases 10% off · code card-prices Display & slab cases For the cards worth showing, not just storing. Shop Zion ↗

Sponsored Affiliate links: Card Prices earns a commission on qualifying purchases from BCW and Zion Cases, at no extra cost to you.

Other printings of Eye for an Eye

  • Arabian Nights
  • Fourth Edition
  • Revised Edition
  • Fourth Edition (Foreign Black Border)

More by Mark Poole ↗

  • Natural Selection Unlimited Edition
  • Phantasmal Forces Unlimited Edition
  • Forest Unsanctioned
  • Dimir Aqueduct (Borderless) Double Masters 2022
  • Panharmonicon (Borderless) Double Masters 2022
  • City of Brass (Borderless) Double Masters 2022
  • Concordant Crossroads (Borderless) Double Masters 2022
  • Ancestral Recall (IE) International Edition
  • Bring to Light Launch Party & Release Event Promos
  • Burrowing (IE) International Edition
  • Yavimaya Coast (Borderless) Dominaria United
  • Howling Mine (IE) International Edition
© 2026 Card Prices LLC · Terms · Privacy · About

Prices from publicly available market data; not affiliated with TCGplayer, eBay or any game publisher. Card Prices may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.